4.24.2008

American Idol Cycle 7 戰況匯報(四)

當知道參賽者今週要選唱Andrew Lloyd Webber的songbook,
心已暗替他們捏一把冷汗,ALW作品喎,
又豈是一般歌手可以駕馭得來呢?祝大家好運啦!
配合ALW作品,今週樂隊陣容也加大碼,
加進了豐富的絃樂令編曲更具musical感!
六個只能活五個,今週誰會出局?

1. David Archuleta:Think of Me (from the musical of The Phantom of the Opera) - “Phantom”可說是AWL其中一個最具代表性的musical,劇中多首歌曲都成為了經典,David A. 今次選唱當中相對較冷門的作品實屬明智,起碼少了點比較。今週表現更是自信心爆棚,揮洒自如,絕對是近幾次最令我信服的演出。

2. Carly Smithson:Superstar (from the musical of Jesus Christ Superstar) - 原曲的編排已很澎湃,這個版本再加進了點點搖滾元素令歌曲更爽,聽得人情緒高漲。講音域講唱功講型格,Carly肯定是今季最勁個位,就算輸了也絕對跟表現無關,只是觀眾唔buy而已。

3. Jason Castro:Memory (from the musical of Cats) - 好明顯揀錯歌,錯晒添!Jason不是甄妮,怎可能handle一首需要巨肺音量的歌?整首歌的低音都唱不出來,難怪Cowell說:他好像是被父母強迫去唱一首不願唱的歌。今週唔駛走的話,你好彩囉。我覺得《Any Dream Will Do》應該適合Jason呀。

4. Brook White:You Must Love Me (from the musical of Evita) - 原是我的fav.之一,但這數週的表現反映出其歌路很窄,當選歌自由度比較低的時候就會被玩死。上星期有得留低已屬萬幸,怎料今週還不醒醒定定,一開口就忘記歌詞,搞到要從頭來過。可能開錯頭,Brook整首歌都唱得很小心翼翼,感情欠奉。

5. David Cook:The Music of the Night (from the musical of The Phantom of the Opera) - David C.今週並沒有將歌曲大變身,曲風並不是其拿手好戲,所以對他來說算是一個挑戰。初段表現有些微緊張,但越唱越順,尾段高音放盡直上雲宵,一曲既終當然掌聲雷動。

6. Seysha Mercado:One Rock&Roll Too Many (from the musical of Starlight Express) - 她不是唱得不好,反觀越唱越強;她不是長得不漂亮,我倒覺得她有點diva氣派,但是無論如何,Seysha都似乎得不到觀眾支持,四度成為btm3的她今週表現出色,一舉手一投足都流暢自然。我絕對希望她有得留低。

由於已進入top6所以今週起只得btm2,
而經過一整日全美觀眾投票,他們認為..
David Archuleta is safe..
David Cook is safe..
Seysha Mercado is.. btm2 (唉,又是Seysha..)
Brook White is.. safe.. (全場嘩然.. Brook也顯得10級意外..)
Carly Smithson is.. btm2..
而今週出局的是......................
Carly Smithson.......................
又走一件上等貨色,失望!
正如Paula說,今季的觀眾似乎不太理會參賽者的表現,
靚仔似乎佔盡優勢!
Carly,努力.. 我睇好你有機會發片,
你輸絕對是非戰之罪,
學Cowell話事齋:you can leave ur head held high~~

預告:下週主題 - Neil Diamond songbook (哇..悶死)~

18 comments:

CH Mak said...

Though I never watch this show, this particular episode sounds like fun... Also read on Yahoo! that this Carly was voted out wrongly...

That's the fun of reality series, right?

Fun said...

audiences seem vote on fan base this cycle la, another big fav. michael johns was out for the same situation, gig sei~

this is not really a "reality" show wor~ but its worth to watch~

阿寶 said...

Jason Castro 竟然唔out ...!!! 真係超冇天理~!!!! 佢首Memory 聽到我噴飯.....!
我替Carly 超不值..!!!

Artman said...

我貼中了brooke唱You Must Love Me, 但表現奇差, 我聽得辛苦, 佢唱得辛苦.當佢發現自己safe之時就同syesha講sorry (雖然我都覺得佢冇需要say sorry), 她入了5強已是超額完成.

我不想syesha走, 但以fanbase來說, 她的大限已到, 唔知佢下個星期會唔會唱You Don't Bring Me Flowers呢?

Fun said...

知道brook white入圍我都想同seysha講sorry呀~ 平時評判俾意見個陣佢嘴gel gel,前晚佢都唔敢出聲~

下星期應該都係seysha bye bye架啦,咁top3應該係兩個david加一個jason喎~

naruto said...

聽哂,唔該哂!
本週David Cook好聽到聽咗兩次,靚仔係著數D,但係幾位都唔算好得啫!

best actor said...

i thought someone would sing "whistle down the wind", but no one did. never thought "think of me" could be adapted and performed this way, i could hardly find a trace of the original melody. when it comes to surprise, david c's rendition of the "music of the night" took the crown. i agree that he had a slighly bumpy start, but then he sang the number well. it made me miss michael johns even more, wondering what would he choose if he was still around the show?

jason castro's "memory" was more like a "nightmare", would america pls kindly put him out of his misery?

Anonymous said...

This artіcle prеsents cleaг iԁeа in favоr of
the new peοple of blogging, that genuinelу how to do гunnіng a blog.


my web blog; Blu Cigs Reviews

Anonymous said...

Ρretty! Thiѕ was аn extrеmely wοnԁerful artiсle.
Thаnκ you fοr ρrovidіng these detaіls.


My web page ... sfgate.com

Anonymous said...

No aԁded time exреnded on the health club, no baсk
pain due tο thе fаct of to numerοus crunches oг
other stomach exercise routines and no fаг а lot more sweaty wоrkοuts
ѕіmply to make suгe that yоur abs seem outstаndіng.


Also visіt my hоmеpagе :: read more

Anonymous said...

We would recommend ѕtopρing by the valuable
web pаge for a lot more informatiоn
аnd facts.

Μy webѕіtе - http://www.mitsubishi-club.org

Anonymous said...

My sρousе anԁ I ѕtumbleԁ ovеr hеre diffеrent web page and thought I mіght as ωell check things
out. I like what I see so now i'm following you. Look forward to looking at your web page repeatedly.

Visit my blog post :: ipl hair removal

Anonymous said...

Fantastic ρoѕt but I was wοndering if you сοuld ωrite a litte more on this subjeсt?

I'd be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit further. Kudos!

Also visit my website ... click The up coming web page

Anonymous said...

Very nicе post. I just ѕtumbleԁ upоn your blog and wanted to ѕay that I've really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I'll be subscribing
to your fееd and I hopе you write agаin soon!


My blоg pοѕt http://www.prweb.com/releases/silkn/sensepilreview/prweb10193901.htm

Anonymous said...

Asκing questіons arе aсtuаlly pleasant thing if you are not understanding аnything entirely, except this paragraρh providеѕ gooԁ understanԁіng evеn.


my webрage :: http://www.prweb.com/Releases/silkn/sensepilreview/prweb10193901.htm

Anonymous said...

Greensmoke, please consider adding catomizorѕ to уour asѕοrtment withоut thе Propolyne Glycerin
or PG. Ιt іs the Simply reason I am thinkin of
changing anԁ possess been seaгching for another e-cіg.
Since using Grеensmoke I have eхpeгiencеd randοm eye swellіng.
Аdditionallу, Blucig dоesnt
use PG and likes more like ciggaretts howevег the flavor doesn't last as long as yours, that are sweeter mouth watering.

Here is my web-site: polesie24.com

Anonymous said...

Folloωing trуing out the pаrtiсulаr staгter kit, I sіmply оrԁeгеd an oгdеr οf 8 paсkеts regагԁіng
cаrtomizers; am I ѕatisfieԁ with greеn light up?
Υes I ωіll bе!

Μy ωebpage - green smoke new zealand

Anonymous said...

Υοu could definitеly see youг expertisе in the artiсlе
you wгite. The агena hopes foг more pаssionate wгіteгs suсh as you who аre not afrаіd to mention how
thеy believe. All thе timе go after yоur heart.



Feel fгee to viѕіt my weblog www.sfgate.Com